Private Use vs Charter in Spain: Where Authorities Draw the Line

Table Of Contents

For many yacht owners, the ultimate goal is a hybrid model: a vessel that operates commercially to offset costs, but remains available for private enjoyment during select weeks of the summer.

While this model works in other Mediterranean jurisdictions, Spain draws a sharp, unforgiving line between “commercial” and “private.”

Many owners assume that occasional payments, shared costs or limited third-party use do not change the legal nature of their yacht’s operation. 

Spanish maritime authorities do not assess intention. They assess activity, registration status and economic reality.

The line is drawn by law, not by how the arrangement is described between parties.

The Core Distinction: Registration Lists and Tax Implications

In Spain, the classification of a yacht as private or commercial is not merely a label; it is the trigger for specific fiscal liabilities.

Formally, this distinction is visible in the registration:

• Private Use (Lista 7ª): Navigation for the owner, family, or guests with no remuneration.
• Commercial Use (Lista 6ª): The vessel is available to third parties for economic consideration under an organized service structure.

However, the critical impact is not administrative, but financial. Under Spanish Law (Ley 38/1992), any vessel over 8 meters used by a resident is subject to a 12% Matriculation Tax (IEDMT). An exemption exists, but it is conditional on the activity being exclusively commercial.

• Commercial (Charter): 0% IEDMT. 100% VAT recovery on expenses.
• Private: 12% IEDMT plus 21% VAT on the hull value.

The legal risk lies in the interaction between these two concepts. Even if a vessel is registered commercially (Lista 6ª), if the factual use implies private enjoyment by the owner without a strict commercial structure, authorities will disregard the label. Unlike jurisdictions that allow “mixed-use” with simple pro-rating, Spain monitors the exclusivity requirement aggressively.

The “Owner Use” Trap: Can I Charter My Own Yacht?

This is the most frequent question we receive: “If I own a charter company, can I rent the boat to myself paying the full market rate?”

The answer depends entirely on whether you claimed the IEDMT exemption.

1. If the yacht is IEDMT Exempt (You paid 0% tax):
   No. The owner, their spouse, descendants, or ascendants cannot use the vessel, even if they pay the full charter fee.
   The Spanish Tax Agency (Agencia Tributaria) views this as a breach of the “exclusive commercial affectation” rule. If the beneficial owner steps on board as a user, the exemption is voided, and the 12% tax becomes due immediately.
2. If the IEDMT was Paid (You paid the 12% tax):
   Yes. You are free to mix private use and third-party charter. However, you must carefully manage VAT deductibility (pro-rating expenses based on the percentage of commercial use).

Why Authorities Care About the Difference: Private Use vs Charter in Spain

This classification affects multiple legal layers:

1. Maritime compliance
   Commercial vessels are subject to stricter safety, manning and inspection regimes.
2. Taxation
   The Spanish Special Tax on Certain Means of Transport (IEDMT), VAT treatment and operational tax obligations may change depending on whether the yacht is deemed commercial.
3. Insurance
   Policies for private pleasure use do not automatically cover commercial passenger activity.
4. Liability exposure
   Transporting third parties under a commercial framework increases exposure and may shift the legal standard applied in case of accident or damage.

The issue is therefore regulatory, fiscal and risk-based, not merely administrative.

Scenario: The “Friends & Fuel” Mistake

To illustrate how easily this line is crossed, consider a scenario we see every season in Ibiza.

An Ultimate Beneficial Owner (UBO) has a yacht registered commercially to a Spanish SL (or a foreign entity operating in Spain). The yacht is exempt from IEDMT because it is 100% for charter.

In July, the owner does not use the boat. However, he allows his brother and some friends to use it for a weekend. They do not sign a charter contract, and they do not pay a commercial fee. They simply cover the APA (fuel, food, and mooring).

The Inspection:
A Customs (Aduanas) or Guardia Civil patrol checks the vessel. They request the charter contract and the crew list.

• The Finding: The passengers are related to the UBO. There is no commercial invoice for the charter fee.
• The Legal Consequence: Authorities classify this as “non-commercial use.” Since the vessel obtained its tax exemption based on exclusive commercial activity, that condition is now breached.
• The Bill: The administration demands the 12% Matriculation Tax on the current value of the yacht, plus interest, plus a potential penalty for tax fraud.

The “free weekend” ends up costing hundreds of thousands of euros.

When “Private” Use Becomes Charter in Practice

Spanish authorities do not rely on a single factor. They look at the economic and operational context.

Situations that frequently trigger reclassification include:

• Guests contributing systematically to costs
• Use of intermediaries or booking structures
• Crew operating under service expectations
• Repeated use by unrelated third parties
• Public or semi-public offering of availability

Even without a formal charter contract, the activity may be treated as commercial if it functions like one.

VAT Implications: The Deductibility Risk

Beyond the Matriculation Tax, “mixed use” creates a complex VAT scenario.

A commercial yacht deducts the VAT (21%) on its purchase, mooring, and maintenance, assuming it is a business asset.
If the authorities detect private use (even if the IEDMT was paid), they may challenge the deductibility of these expenses.

• Autoconsumo (Self-Supply): If an owner uses the boat, it may be treated as a “payment in kind” or self-supply, requiring the company to pay VAT on the value of that use.

The “Matriculation” Solution: Paying to Be Free

Given these risks, when does it make sense to pay the 12% tax?

For owners who prioritize operational freedom over tax efficiency, paying the IEDMT is often the smartest legal strategy. By settling the tax:

1. The owner can use the vessel anytime without fear of inspection.
2. The vessel can still be chartered to third parties to generate revenue.
3. The risk of a catastrophic tax penalty disappears.

Risk Management Before Operating

Preventive assessment is essential before allowing third-party use of a yacht in Spain. Key elements include:

• Reviewing registration status and permitted activity
• Confirming tax implications of the intended use
• Ensuring insurance matches operational reality
• Understanding regional enforcement sensitivity, particularly in the Balearic Islands

Most problems do not arise from deliberate non-compliance. They arise from assuming that informal arrangements fall outside the regulatory framework.

FAQs – Private Use vs Charter in Spain

Can an owner charter their own yacht in Spain?
If the yacht is exempt from Matriculation Tax (IEDMT), the answer is generally no. Use by the owner or related parties (spouse, children) breaches the exemption conditions, even if a market price is paid.

What triggers the 12% Matriculation Tax?
The tax is triggered by the registration of a yacht in Spain, or by its use in Spanish waters by a Spanish tax resident. It applies to all pleasure craft unless they are exclusively dedicated to commercial activity.

Can I use my charter boat for free if it’s not booked?
No. If the boat is commercial, allowing friends or family to use it for free is considered “private use.” This compromises the IEDMT exemption and creates VAT liabilities under the “self-supply” rules.

Is it better to pay the tax or claim the exemption?
If you plan to use the boat yourself for significant periods, paying the tax provides legal certainty and freedom. The exemption is only viable for vessels that are purely business assets with zero private use by the owner.

Can I let friends use my yacht if they cover expenses?
It depends on the frequency, structure and economic reality. Repeated or organised arrangements may be treated as commercial use.

Does a foreign flag avoid Spanish charter rules?
No. Operational use in Spanish waters can trigger Spanish regulatory and tax implications regardless of flag.

This article provides general legal information and does not constitute legal advice. For case-specific guidance, please contact Almar Lawyers.

Discover all our services and contact our experts now. Follow us on Linkedin to make sure you don’t miss a thing.